As the streaming growth wave begins to plateau, major labels like Warner, UMG, and Sony are confronting significant challenges in maintaining their growth Superfans are the key. For years, labels have benefited from the double-digit growth of streaming, boosting both their income and share prices. However, this growth hasn’t necessarily been for the benefit of the artists. There’s even the question of whether labels are truly invested in the music industry or merely profiting from decades of back catalog music while perpetuating the narrative that “streaming is great for artists.” To thrive in the new landscape, they need to refocus on superfans.
Historical Reliance on Superfans
Superfans have always been the backbone of the music industry. Before the era of streaming, initially caused by the panic at the rise of Napster and the pirating of music, the music industry’s revenue relied heavily on superfans and the passionate fandom that drove physical product sales. These superfans were, and still are, the ones who attend concerts, buy vinyl, CDs, and merchandise. They are the lifeblood of the industry, despite representing a much smaller market segment compared to casual music listeners.
Superfans vs. Casual Listeners
| Attribute | Superfans | Casual Listeners |
|---|---|---|
| Engagement Level | High | Low |
| Spending Habits | Buy physical products, merch, tickets | Mostly consume music via streaming |
| Market Segment Size | 2-3% of the population | Vast majority |
| Revenue Contribution | Significant | Moderate |
Complacency with Streaming Revenue
The Rise of Streaming
In recent years, the ease, profitability, and lower risk of streaming revenue led labels to focus less on physical sales and more on digital distribution. Reliance on streaming’s incredible growth and ability to monetize casual music listeners made labels complacent. Sometimes it takes a crisis to spark new thinking. While labels do recognize the value of superfans, they haven’t fully capitalized on this market, likely because streaming platform income was more straightforward, more profitable, and less labor-intensive. However, there’s no logistical reasons labels couldn’t work with artist branded platforms that allow them to stream music directly.
Challenges with Streaming
- Limited Growth: Streaming platform growth in terms of user numbers has stagnated.
- Revenue Share: Artists often receive a smaller share of revenue from streaming.
- Market Saturation: Nearly everyone who listens to music is already on streaming platforms.
Current Challenges and the Need for Superfans
Monetizing Superfans
We are now at a critical juncture. Streaming broadened the audience to encompass nearly everyone who listens to music, but labels have yet to find a sustainable way to monetize superfans—the dedicated followers who were instrumental in their past success. Their challenge is compounded by the fact that the superfan market is smaller. Superfans represent only 2-3% of the population, while the rest are casual music listeners who probably never bought a record, attended a concert, or purchased an artist’s merchandise. When you have shareholders, the last thing you want to show is shrinking growth and a smaller addressable market. The reality is that they need to think outside the box and find innovative solutions and concentrate on superfans, at least for newer artists sand new music. Of course, back catalog music probably belongs on streaming networks, but only when it’s value has been extracted, in the same way movies begin at cinemas and slowly move down chain to DVDs, paid downloads and eventually to planforms like Netflix. A recent study found superfans are the most important growth area in the music industry.
The Key Takeaways
- Superfans Drive Revenue: Superfans have always mattered the most and will continue to do so.
- Engagement is Crucial: Engaging superfans in meaningful ways is essential for long-term success.
- Market Size: Superfans represent a smaller but highly valuable market segment.
Strategies for Future Success
To thrive in this new landscape, labels must innovate and find meaningful ways to engage and monetize their most loyal fans. This might include:
- Exclusive Releases: Limited edition albums and singles.
- Limited Edition Merchandise: Specially designed and rare merchandise items.
- VIP Concert Experiences: Exclusive access to behind-the-scenes experiences and meet-and-greets.
Leveraging Superfan Platforms
Platforms like FanCircles can help foster deeper connections between artists and superfans through tailored experiences and direct interactions. These platforms offer a unique opportunity to:
- Enhance Fan Interaction: Personalized interactions between artists and superfans.
- Offer Exclusive Content: Behind-the-scenes footage, early access to new music, and special events.
- Build a Community: Create a dedicated space for superfans to connect and share their passion.
Benefits of Superfan Platforms
| Benefit | Description |
|---|---|
| Direct Revenue Streams | Monetize fan engagement through subscriptions and exclusive content |
| Enhanced Fan Loyalty | Strengthen the bond between artists and superfans |
| Data Insights | Gain valuable insights into fan preferences and behaviors |
| Customized Experiences | Tailor content and interactions to meet the specific interests of superfans |
The Tipping Point
As the traditional distribution channels like Spotify and Apple Music reach their growth limits, the music industry stands at a tipping point. The future success of major labels will depend on how quickly and effectively they can pivot back to valuing and monetizing their superfans. Embracing this dedicated audience is not just a nostalgic return to old practices but a necessary evolution to ensure sustained growth and profitability in the ever-changing music landscape.
Superfans are the key to the future. By recognizing their importance and finding innovative ways to engage and monetize them, music labels can navigate the challenges of the modern music industry and continue to thrive.
